Research, evaluation and learning for better experiences.UX audits · Research · Training
Utility Experience Transformation · Concept usability study

Making everyday account and payment tasks easier to understand.

A utility mobile app and web portal redesign needed to support routine payments, multiple accounts and different levels of digital confidence.

34concept-study participants
2design concepts compared
15participants in later workflow testing
2channels: app and web
A programme of connected research

From concept choice to the detail of everyday transactions.

Method, sample and scope make the evidence meaningful. Here is how the work was structured.

Study design

Concept comparison, usability testing and later workflow validation

Session mode

Prototype task observation; remote / in-person mode not specified in the reports

Participants

Existing users in the concept study; individual and professional roles in later testing

Measures

First-attempt completion, repeated-attempt completion, failure and stated preference

01

Explore the direction

Compare two concepts through payment and navigation tasks.

Concept preference + task findings
02

Understand the workflow

Desk research, journey analysis and subject-matter-expert walkthroughs.

Validated flows + prototype direction
03

Test the details

Evaluate access, account, billing and professional-user workflows.

Task-level findings + recommended refinements
01 / CONCEPT EVALUATION

Visual preference and task performance told different stories.

The concept study recorded a strong preference for one visual direction. The more complex payment task revealed a different pattern. Both forms of evidence were needed to decide what to retain and what to refine.

REPORTED VISUAL PREFERENCE
Concept A · 76.48%B · 23.52%
Stated preference from the concept report; not task completion.
FIRST-ATTEMPT COMPLETIONReported study data

The difficult payment task separated the concepts.

Reported percentages from the concept study. Completion means success on the first attempt. Task-level denominators are not given in the summary table; no statistical significance or before-and-after improvement is inferred.
View exact values
MeasureConcept AConcept B
Pay full amount100%100%
Select account + edit amount46.67%76.47%
Switch theme100%100%
01

Retain a preferred foundation

Concept A was preferred visually, while Concept B performed better on the account-and-amount task.

DESIGN IMPLICATIONUse preference to inform the direction, then refine the interactions.
02

Make payment choices explicit

Participants struggled to select a different account or edit the amount at review.

DESIGN IMPLICATIONExpose account and amount controls where the payment is confirmed.
03

Continue beyond the concept

Later testing extended into account access, billing and professional-user journeys.

DESIGN IMPLICATIONEvaluate the detail of each role’s workflow rather than stopping at look and feel.
02 / WORKFLOW COVERAGE

Follow the experience from access to action.

Access

Registration · login · identity verification

Account

Profile selection · linked accounts · account details

Payment

Amount selection · payment methods · review

Information

Bills · account information · professional dashboards

Scope summary across the supplied research stages. Separate samples are shown separately; the reports do not establish a combined count of unique participants.

OBSERVE THE WORKThe UX Faculty
Our perspective
The most useful finding is the one that changes what you build next.

Real people. Real tasks. Evidence that gives the next design decision a reason.

THE WORK PRODUCED

Evidence that carries into the next decision.

Concept comparison
Task outcome tables
User-flow validation
Payment findings
Role-specific findings
Design recommendations

Concept testing report, pp. 6–8, 15 and 22; later workflow research report, methodology and usability findings. The later 15-person sample appears in related reports and is counted once here.

FROM EVIDENCE TO ACTION

What the work made possible.

The research separated straightforward payment tasks from the account-management interactions that needed further design work.

Recommended next steps

  • Make account selection and amount editing explicit at the payment-review step.
  • Clarify the relationship between personal and professional profiles.
  • Carry unresolved issues into focused workflow testing.
YOUR NEXT STEP

What would you like to do better?

Tell us about your product, your questions or the skills you want to build.

Discuss your goals